Search

1st Annual Filament Olympics

Spread the love
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

1st Annual Filament Olympics
5 (100%) 5 votes

The Olympic and Paralympic Games are an amazing show of athletic talent from around the world. As the world watches the best compete for the gold medal, I wanted to see how all the filaments that I have tested compare to each other.

Just like gymnastics, there is a complex grading system that I can use to rate the desired properties of a 3D printing filament. For the first annual Filament Olympics,  I will review all the filaments against each other in the following categories.

PLA / PHA, Other Polymers, and Exotic filaments.


PLA / PHA

This is by far the largest field in the Filament Olympics. PLA and PLA / PHA  are popular blends of plastic for beginning to experienced 3D printers. Any company entering the filament field must be able to produce a quality polymer that does not warp.

The competing countries: Canada, China, Netherlands, Portugal, USA.

USA Flag
USA Flag

canada

china

Netherlands Flag
Netherlands Flag

portugal


RESULTS

USA Company MeltInk  is a new contestant in the Olympics. I originally wanted to print replica Olympic medals with their gold and silver PLA and PLA / PHA samples, but instead I used them to revise the spool of thrones holder  that I designed. The gold filament has a rich honey glow that would be great for toys and artistic prints. The silver PLA / PHA likewise was a solid print material with a matte shine that would be good for cosplay props.

MeltInk Gold and Silver PLA / PHA printing a spool of thrones holder
MeltInk Gold and Silver PLA / PHA printing a spool of thrones holder

Flexibility: 12 pts      Color: 3 pts    Starting Quality: 2 pts          Warping: Slight warping 2 pts       End of Print: 3 pts     Environmental: 2 pts           Special consideration: 1 pt             Processing: 1

Final Score: 25 / 28

Canada: Filaments3DQubec 2.85 mm 25 /28

China: Beaver Silk – like 2.85 mm 27.5 / 28

China: 3DDPlus Multigradient 1.75 mm  26 / 28

China: Wenotion 2.85 mm  27 / 28

China: Prototype Supply 1.75 mm  27 / 28

China: Prototype Supply  22 / 28

Netherlands: ColorFabb 2.85 and 1.75 mm  28 / 28

Portugal: Bee Supply 1.75 mm  16 / 28

USA: MakerBot 1.75mm 22.3 / 28


WINNERS PLA / PHA

Netherlands Flag
Netherlands Flag

Gold: Netherlands: ColorFabb 2.85 and 1.75 mm 28 / 28

Silver: China: Beaver Silk – like 2.85 mm 27.5 / 28

Bronze: Two way tie,

China: Wenotion 2.85 mm 27 / 28

China: Prototype Supply 1.75 mm 27 / 28


Other Plastics

3D printing is exploding with new plastics coming on the market daily. These new brand of polymers have better mechanical and printing qualities than PLA / PHA, and produce a wide range of properties that may be desired for industrial 3D prints.

The competing countries: Netherlands


RESULTS

Netherland: Colorfabb nGen: 24 / 28

Netherland: ColorFabb HT 24 / 28

Netherland: ColorFabb Xt

26.5 / 28


WINNERS Other Plastics

Netherlands Flag
Netherlands Flag

Gold: Netherlands: ColorFabb XT

Silver: Two way tie, Netherlands: Colorfabb HT and nGen


Exotics

Exotic blends of filament are another exciting class of filaments coming to the market. They combine the printing abilities of PLA with the mechanical properties of a composite material to produce amazing industrial and artistic prints.

The competing countries: USA, Netherlands


RESULTS

Netherlands: ColorFabb Glow Fill PLA / PHA 26 / 28

USA: NinjaFlex 2.85 mm TPU 27 /28

USA: SemiFlex 2.85 TPU 27 / 28

USA: INprinting Hemp Based HIPS Filament 23 / 28

USA: Proto Pasta Stainless Steel 18.8/28

USA: Proto Pasta Magnetic Iron 18.8 / 28

USA: Proto Pasta Aromatic Coffee 24.2 / 28

USA Proto Pasta Conductive 23.2 /28

USA: 3Dom USA Buzzed 21.6 / 28

USA: 3Dom USA Glass Filled 21.75 / 28

USA: 3Dom USA Wound Up 23.3 / 28


WINNERS EXOTIC

USA Flag
USA Flag

Gold: USA: NinjaFlex and SemiFlex  27 /28

Silver: Netherlands: ColorFabb Glow Fill PLA / PHA 26 / 28

Bronze: USA Wound Up (coffee)  23.3 / 28


This is a compilation of the filament reviews for this year. Please check the links for full details of each filaments performance. If you would like to participate in the next annual filament Olympics, please contact 3D-PT in the comments or stan@3dpt.club to review your filaments.


Spread the love
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Profile photo of 3D-PT

Written by 

3D-PT is a small 3D printing company started by a science teacher with autism. He has a background in CAD and science education, and believes that 3D printing can be used to help the world. 3D-PT develops products for people with autism and other disabilities. 3D-PT is also developing 3D printable products for education. 3D-PT is online at 3dpt.club Twitter: @3dfidgets

Related posts

4 thoughts on “1st Annual Filament Olympics

  1. Ben

    I don’t understand why you didn’t do ABS.

    1. I Don’t normally work with ABS due to environmental concerns and frustration with warping. I also feel other materials showcase the properties of a filament maker better.

  2. I hope to see pictures of all test, sometimes the looks worths more than the quality of some material due the destination of the print.

    1. Review the links for pics of each filament in testing.

Leave a Comment