What about the Spools? Empty Spools and MasterSpool Standards

What should we do with empty filament spools?

19 7,501

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

What about the Spools? Empty Spools and MasterSpool Standards
4.9 (97.33%) 15 votes

Richard Horne has proposed the MasterSpool to replace the piles of empty spools that build up while 3D printing. As printers end up with the empty spools, we are left wondering what to do with them?

One of the goals of 3D printing was to reduce the amount plastic waste on the Earth by recycling plastic water bottles into new filament. I found earlier from testing 3R3DTM  filament that the PET used is difficult to 3D print. When you combine the difficulty of printing and recycling filaments, most beginning 3D printers do not make or recycle their own filament.

Combine this difficulty with the popularity of PLA and polymer blends of filaments, and most 3D printers are facing another environmental issue. As printers order and 3D print objects, they are left with the empty filament spools. Many spools are made with ABS, Poly Carbonate (PC), or other plastics that may not be accepted in all municipal recycling facilities.This has resulted in a growing issue with 3D printing, and different companies have taken different approaches to the spool issue.

ProtoPasta has distinguished themselves as a filament firm by producing not only special limited edition blends of filaments  but they have also distinguished themselves by their environmentally friendlier cardboard spools. Not only can they print more vibrant graphics onto the cardboard spools, the spools can easily be recycled in municipal paper / cardboard recycling facilities. Cardboard is also biodegradable, which also limits the environmental impact in municipal garbage dumps. These cardboard spools are light weight and bypass the plastic issue.

MasterSpool ideas from spools
Different spools, including colorfabb PC 750 g (2d from Right) and ProtoPasta cardboard spools. Photo from https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2769823

Filamnentive actually encourages 3D printers to reuse emptied spools by offering a 20% discount on future orders. This spool return program helps the company out in that they don’t have to purchase spools. However, it does not address the fact that the carbon footprint generated will increase as the empty spools are shipped from consumer back to the factory. The consumer also pays shipping cost to the UK company, so it is not economical outside the UK.

3D fuel (formally 3DomUSA), makes their spools from the same PLA base as their wound (coffee) and buzzed (beer) based filaments. This looks great, but I found in my outdoor experiments that PLA can take years to biodegrade.

With this in mind, what are some ways to take care of our empty spools?

Recycling

Recycling is touted in elementary schools as a great way to care for the planet. Recycling is a economically and ecologically viable way to recycle metals; plastics however have been problematic.

Different plastics require different methods to recycle. Petrochemical plastics like ABS and PC may not melt down for reuse.  Many recycling facilities limit the type of plastic that they can take in, which can impact you if your local facility can’t take plastics like ABS or PC.

Recycling plastics also takes energy, which may not help in reducing the carbon foot print involved in the plastic cycle.

Re-melting filament and spools

Advanced 3D printers may get a filament recycling system like Filastruder, and would

Filastruder for MasterSpools
Filastruder to recycle filament and empty spools. photo from https://www.filastruder.com/products/filastruder-kit?variant=338125893

benefit directly from recycling misprints and scraping empty spools. This may be a viable option for 3D printer companies that run printer farms like Lulzbot  and Prusa, where they

can recycle and make bulk filament in house to reduce the amount they consume. Schools and makerspaces may also benefit from re melting filaments and empty spools in house. Individual 3D printers may be hard pressed to justify purchasing a filament system.

Up Cycle / Re-purpose

An empty spool can be a canvas for designers. As a utilitarian object, spools are re purposed frequently into workbench trays for small parts

spool bot
Spoolbot made from empty spools. Photo from https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:25185

. Other creative uses include a spoolbot  that uses the spools for the wheels and body of a robot. Others may find other creative ways to upcycle these spools, but the number of spools produced will vastly outnumber the small number of projects that can be done

Sell / give away locally

Someone may have a use for a box full of empty spools for a project or craft storage. A quick look on ebay and amazon has the price for an individual 1 kg spool around $1-$10 USD, and cases of spools listed around $50. It is doubtful that anyone needs a large number of spools, so your better bet will be to see if you can give them away locally on Craigslist or Facebook.


MasterSpool

A new concept has emerged from Richard Horne . In his work in RipRep, he has devised the MasterSpool concept that bypasses the need for spools to be shipped in the first place.

 

Horne’s MasterSpool concept ships a coil of filament bound in minimum packaging (3 zip ties and a vacuum sealed bag). The resulting MasterSpool refill can then be loaded onto a MasterSpool which you can 3D print at home, or purchase from the filament company.

3D printer companies can add a MasterSpool as an accessory to their printers, or filament companies can also produce MasterSpools as a premium for their filament.

From the start, MasterSpool refills have many advantages over shipping filament with a bulky spool.

a. Lower shipping weight for the same amount of filament. Many plastic spools weigh in from 200 – 300 g, where as the bag and zip ties for MasterSpool may come in under 20 g.

b. Much less packaging to be recycled or trashed. Less space is taken up in a landfill by a flattened bag.

c. No empty spools to deal with when you run out of filament. The MasterSpool can be easily refilled and reused.

A Move towards MasterSpool Standards

Different filament companies currently use their own dimensions of filament spools to ship their products, which has not created an industry standard for production units of filament.

Richard Horne explored the wide variety of filament spools in this blog from 2014. MasterSpools may create a standard size for 3D printing filaments that all manufactures can adopt.

In looking at the different filament companies and sizes, I developed some standard size MasterSpools can be used for the bulk of filaments produced on the market today. In looking at the standard spools and bobbins use in the wire and textile industry, I do not see it as stretch for filament companies to adapt some standard size MasterSpool coils and spools for the 3D printing community.

MasterSpool refill dimensions.
MasterSpool V4 dimensions. Photo from MasterSpool_v4_information.pdf

Just as batteries and shoes come in some industrial standard sizes, so to can the amount of filament that companies can make for a MasterSpool. I looked online at the shipping size of different spools, as well as the various esun, Colorfabb and makerbot spools that I had on hand.

Proposed MasterSpool Sizes

Size Amount of filament Mounting diameter (mm) Outer Spool

Diameter (mm)

Core Width (mm) Internal Coil Diameter (mm)
AAA 100 g – 250 g         50 120 25 80
AA 500 g 200 35 105
A 750 g 200 45 105
B 2.2 kg 300 90 220
C 4.5 kg 300 140 220

I kept the mounting hole at 50 mm for all MasterSpool because there is a large amount of spool holders already available that can hold 50 mm mounting holes.

AAA size would be great for samples and Nylons which have a short shelf life.

AA would be a good size for beginner printers and expensive composite filaments. Many companies already sell their composite filaments in the 500 g range.

A size seems to be an industry standard for many companies already, with many of their commercial lines of filament sold in the 500 – 750 g range.

B size would be good for bulk printers and schools.

C would be an ideal size for printer companies that have a 3D printer farm like Lulzbot  or Prusa. German company Das Filament has become an early adaptor of the MasterSpool, and sells MasterSpool refills along with

I would like feedback from filament companies and printers on these standards. Please leave a comment or use the hashtag #MasSpoolStd on social media.

MasterSpool files can be found at https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:2769823, or https://www.youmagine.com/designs/masterspool-for-3d-printing-filament-v4 and his blog at https://richrap.blogspot.co.uk/2018/01/masterspool-proposed-standard-for-3d.html

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

19 Comments
  1. Daniel Faegnell says

    Awesome i was wondering what to do with the empty filament spools.

    1. Stan Baldwin says

      While it is possible to repurpose the spools, the most common project has been the storage trays. In reality, you only need 3-4 in your workspace for your loose screws and hardware, so they wont be a sustainable solution for spools.

  2. Richard Bynum says

    I wish all businesses started doing recycling when they started out. But hindsight is 20/20 right? We didn’t see what kind of problems the future held. Or maybe we did but was just too lazy to do anything about it. I really respect ProtoPasta and Richard Horne for doing their part and working to make things better. The printed yellow/red masterspool (in the pick) is awesome and the answer to all the empty spools laying around the house!

    1. Stan Baldwin says

      Das Filament has jumped on the bandwagon, and other filament companies are testing masterSpool refills now. It’s going to take market response for filament compaines to adopt masterspool standards, but it is something that can be done with enough pressure from the community.

      1. Richard Bynum says

        Nice! Yes, it’s going to “take a village” to change the current way filaments are sent out. You would think the filament companies would love being able to send them out without the spool. Those pennies add up over time and they would have a small benefit at the end of the year…Not much but maybe 5 years would be nice.

  3. Tom Baxter says

    I remember seeing Horne’s idea about a MasterSpool a while back and thought that it was genius. I certainly don’t print as much as many other hobbyists, and I was wondering what to do with my growing pile of spools. It is great to see that companies are embracing this concept. My next step is to get a printer with a bed large enough to print my own MasterSpools.

    1. Stan Baldwin says

      IF you have access to a cad prgram, you can cut the origional file down to print in sections on a smaller printer, or use 3D hubs and have someone local print you a full size spool

      1. Tom Baxter says

        I have been playing in TinkerCAD a lot lately. I’ll have to try and print it in sections. My only concern is the number of glued joints the final piece will have. (working with a 120x120x120 print volume) Then again, I cant imagine that the spool will undergo that much stress in normal use.

        Thanks Stan.

  4. David says

    3D filament suppliers should make the spool optional and offer a split spool. After you have acquired a few spools you can just buy the filament. Saving everyone material and money.

  5. John Smith says

    I too had lots of filament spools left with me and was wondering what to do with them. This blog offers me some of the best solutions for the same. Though, I tried to use my wits to convert them to something useful, but was short of enough brains. Credits to the writer!

  6. Brian Martin says

    Great concept, great Idea, how ever sadly no one will pay more for filament (premium or not) with no spool rather then pay less for ones with spools. I’m not against this concept I just wish I could get the same amount of filament for the same or less without the spool.

    1. Stan Baldwin says

      I think if we generate interest with the filament company they will make the switch. If not master spool, than to a cardboard spool or other idea.

  7. john willoughby says

    https://www.3dqf.co.uk/environmental-impact

    i use this uk company for my 3d printer filament. Their spools are 100% recyclable. they are made of cardboard and steel. They are also one of the cheapest suppliers i have found charging £12.99 for a 1kg pla spool of filament delivered.

  8. Carol Oddy says

    I really liked the idea using cardboard spools although the master spool is also a great idea. I would use empty spools for craft projects and as you have said for small parts storage.

  9. AJ Tucker says

    Maybe I’m just dumb, but this stuff is a little too complicated for me.

  10. Jamie B says

    cardboard or other biodegradable spool seems to be a good way to go.

  11. Sarah says

    awsome x

  12. Jim Spencer says

    Isn’t 1kg the most common filament quantity? Is it assumed that the “B” sized spool would be the right choice for this, or is 1kg not a quantity that MasterSpool manufacturers will offer?

  13. Jimi Carmen Sanchez says

    i’ve been letting my oldest son play with them.. he turns them into all kinds of cool toys

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.